Two of the most common fencing materials homeowners prefer are pine and cedar. Pine wood is more affordable, but it requires more maintenance. On the other hand, cedar lasts longer, but it’s more expensive. So, which is better for fencing, pine or cedar? Below, we’ll determine which wood is best for various needs and delve into the pros and cons of each option.

Which Is Better for Fencing, Pine or Cedar?

Homeowners must consider several factors when choosing between cedar or pine, including cost, durability and maintenance. You’ll also need to consider your location and the climate in your area. Finally, the cost of installing and maintaining your fence should be considered.

Why Choose a Cedar Fence

Here are some of the reasons why people should use cedar wood to build a fence:

• Aesthetic Appeal

Cedar wood is easily recognizable with its distinct reddish hue and unique grain pattern on the surface. Its white accents also create a warm and attractive look on any fence. In addition, it looks more natural than pine, making it eye-catching.

• Durability

Cedar, like pine, is a type of softwood with plenty of applications. However, cedar wood is more resistant and durable. Its natural oils protect it from insects and other potential causes of decay.

• Lighter Weight

Cedar weighs lighter compared to pine. This means it is easier to cut, shape and form. As a result, they’re easier to carry around and easier to install.

• Low Maintenance

Cedar fences require less maintenance compared to those made with pine. This is because it doesn’t need to be pressure treated before it can be used to build a fence. However, cedar also requires routine maintenance, so it lasts longer. 

• Durability

Cedar is more durable overall compared to pine wood. This wood doesn’t require any special treatment before use and doesn’t shrink or warp when exposed to the elements.

Cedar Fence Cons

One of the most significant downsides to building cedar fences is the cost. It can easily cost around twice that of a pine fence, and the wood is hard to find. Further, this type of wood doesn’t last long in humid areas and is less soil-resistant, so you need to construct it above the soil.

To sum it up, here are the pros and cons of using cedar for fences:

Pros

• Lightweight
• Eye-catching red hue
• Excellent for places with a dry climate
• It comes with a pleasant odor
• Doesn’t require a lot of maintenance
• Environment-friendly option
• Natural looking

Cons

• More expensive
• Doesn’t last long in humid areas
• Less soil-resistant
• More expensive

Why Choose Pine for Your Fence

Here are some of the reasons why some homeowners prefer to use pine for fence installation:

• Cost-Effective Option

You can easily find pine, and it’s readily available from many suppliers. Cedar, on the other hand, is a rare type of wood. Because of this supply issue, pine is usually more affordable than cedar, which is why many homeowners prefer to use it for their fences.

• Better Suited for Humid Climates

Pine fences will be the better option if you live in humid areas with regular rainfall. Cedar is a type of dry wood better suited for sunny neighborhoods. If it gets wet more often, it tends to expand. That is not the case for pressure-treated pine.

• Soil Resistance

Pine is more resistant to rot when exposed or gets contact with soil. Because of this, homeowners use pine for the fence posts instead of cedar.

Pine Fence Cons

Pine wood isn’t perfect, and it has its downsides as well. It has a shorter lifespan and is less durable compared to cedar wood. It requires chemical treatment before installation, making it less environment-friendly. It doesn’t look as natural as cedar, meaning you must paint it to improve its aesthetics.

Select the Best Material for Your Fence

So, which is better for fencing, pine or cedar? The answer depends on several factors, such as the availability of the wood, the climate in your area and your budget. If you need help determining which type of wood is best for your fence, you should get expert professional help.

Nortex Fence & Patio has over two decades worth of experience building fences. We can help you source the right wood for your home’s fence. Call 972-382-7800 today or fill out this contact form to get a free estimate.